Tuesday, April 26, 2005

Yahoo My Web and searching web history

Yahoo launched My Web, an extension to the Yahoo Toolbar that lets you save on Yahoo's servers a copy of any web page you've seen. The idea is that it lets you find web pages you saw once before quickly and easily.

This isn't quite like Seruku, which saves a copy of every web page you've seen on your own computer. Or quite like Google Desktop Search, which searches over every web page you've seen recently (using the browser cache on your computer). Or quite like Filangy, which (sort of) stores every page you've seen on their servers.

Because you have to explicitly push a button to save the page, I'm not sure how many people will use Yahoo My Web. Seems likely to me that, when I'm browsing a particular page, I don't really know if I'll want to find it again. It'll be too late when I decide I really should have pushed that little button.

Cute idea though. Fun to see all the innovation lately.

See also Chris Sherman's review of Yahoo My Web.

Update: Tony Gentile posts a detailed review. He also points out that Yahoo My Web probably should be considered more of a bookmarking tool than a step toward Memex.


Hashim said...

good point.

It would be cool if you could turn on a feature that lets you save every page, or turn it off and push a button to save a page

Derek said...

It sounds like bookmarks. I press a button to bookmark a page all the time, too often in fact; I have a ton of bookmarks to clean up.

Greg Linden said...

Well, yes, Yahoo My Web does sound like bookmarks.

The problem with bookmarks is that you do have to explicitly decide to mark a page in order to find it again. As you say, that may put Yahoo My Web in a different class than the more interesting tools that try to recall everything you've ever seen.

We could compare Yahoo My Web to other bookmark tools, but that comparison wouldn't be particularly good for Yahoo. There are hundreds of server-side bookmarking tools out there already. If that's all Yahoo My Web is, it isn't a new product or an interesting technology.

However, Yahoo has indicated that it intends to integrate Yahoo My Web into Yahoo 360. If that happens, that could be more interesting. Perhaps it would look something like the more innovative social bookmarking tools like del.icio.us and de.lirio.us.